VIDEO: Chardon school killer defiant at sentencing

Makes obscene gesture, comments, to victim families
Associated Press
Mar 19, 2013

Wearing a T-shirt with "killer" scrawled across it, a teenager cursed and gestured obscenely as he was given three life sentences Tuesday for shooting to death three students in an Ohio high school cafeteria.

Watch this video clip from today's hearing. 

T.J. Lane, 18, had pleaded guilty last month to shooting at students in February 2012 at Chardon High School, east of Cleveland. Investigators have said he admitted to the shooting but said he didn't know why he did it.

Before the case went to adult court last year, a juvenile court judge ruled that Lane was mentally competent to stand trial despite evidence he suffers from hallucinations, psychosis and fantasies.

Lane was defiant during the sentencing, smiling and smirking throughout, including while four relatives of victims spoke.

After he came in, he calmly unbuttoned his blue dress shirt to reveal the T-shirt reading "killer," which the prosecutor noted was similar to one he wore during the shooting.

At one point, he swiveled around in his chair toward the gallery where his own family members and those of the slain teenagers were sitting and spoke suddenly, surprising even his lawyer.

"The hand that pulled the trigger that killed your sons now masturbates to the memory," he said, then cursed at and raised his middle finger toward the victims' relatives.

A student who was wounded in the rampage dismissed the outburst.

"He said it like a scared little boy and couldn't talk slow enough that anyone could understand him," said Nate Mueller, who was nicked in the ear in the shooting.

Dina Parmertor, mother of victim Daniel, called Lane "a pathetic excuse for a human being" and wished upon him "an extremely, slow torturous death." She said she has nightmares and her family has been physically sick over the crimes.

"From now on, he will only be a killer," she said, as Lane's smile widened. "I want him to feel my anger toward him."

Prosecutors say Lane took a .22-caliber pistol and a knife to the school and fired 10 shots at a group of students in the cafeteria. Daniel Parmertor and Demetrius Hewlin, both 16, and Russell King Jr., 17, were killed.

Lane was at Chardon waiting for a bus to the alternative school he attended, for students who haven't done well in traditional settings.

Six days before the rampage, Lane had sent a text message to his sister, who attended Chardon High school, and mentioned a school shooting, Geauga County Prosecutor James Flaiz disclosed after the sentencing. He gave no details about what the message said.

"The way the text message was phrased to his sister, I'm not sure she would have taken it as anything. I think only when you look at it in retrospect does it really have the impact that it does now," Flaiz said.

Lane's sister, Sadie, was in the cafeteria the day of the shooting, and said outside the snow-swept courthouse that the brother she saw in court wasn't the one she remembers. She asked for prayers for her family.

"It may be hard for some to understand, but I love my brother and hope that whatever the sentencing in life takes him in the future, that he can touch others' lives in a positive way from the point of view that only he can give," she said.

She spoke and left the courthouse before Flaiz addressed reporters.

Flaiz said he has a theory about the motive but wouldn't discuss it until he has a chance to meet with the families of victims and answer their questions.

Lane's courtroom behavior came as a surprise, he added.

" I am totally disgusted by that," Flaiz said. "What he did today is consistent with what we thought of him all along."

One of Lane's defense attorneys, Ian Friedman, also said he was caught off-guard by the comments. The defense had signaled earlier that Lane wouldn't speak in court and didn't want anyone to speak for him.

Lane had pleaded guilty last month to three counts of aggravated murder, two counts of attempted aggravated murder and one count of felonious assault.

Life imprisonment without parole was the maximum sentence Lane faced. He wasn't eligible for the death penalty because he was 17 at the time of the shootings. Relatives of the slain students indicated earlier they wanted Lane to get the maximum sentence.

In addition to three life sentences without chance of parole, Geauga County Common Pleas Judge David Fuhry also gave Lane sentences totaling 37 additional years for attempted murder and felonious assault and using a weapon in the crimes.

------
Associated Press freelance reporter John Coyne contributed to this report.

Comments

Cowboy

What a moron!

tiredofthecrap

Hope he rots!

Eph 2 8-10

I'd love to wipe the smirk off of his face, but the Lord will take care of it for the next 50-60 years, if he lives that long.

Cowboy

And then he meets Bubba!

BULLISDEEP's picture
BULLISDEEP

Maybe he will get the same as this guy .http://www.portclintonnewsherald...

BULLISDEEP's picture
BULLISDEEP
NotForLong

The anger I feel when I watch that video is almost more than I can stand. I applaud the family members who were able to maintain their composure in the court room. I do not think I would've been capable of showing such self-control and restraint.
I consider myself to be a kind and compassionate person, but I can't help but to wish anything but pain and misery on this individual. He is repulsive.

Just Saying

No fake remorse? His attorneys must not have educated him enough - that's what free counsel gets you.

Centauri

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z...
Flipping the bird to victims family members? He will be crying very soon to get out of prison.

Cowboy

You can't fix stupid!

Not Yer Pa

Sure you can. Lethal injection.

Julie R.

I agree with the student that dismissed his outburst saying he sounded like a scared little boy.

Perkahontas

You guys still support his 2nd amendment rights though, right?

ladydye_5

HE is underage....he has NO 2nd amendment rights. There are GUN LAWS in effect that are not enforced properly.

Super Judge

It is better that we have 1000 Chardons than for even one legal gun owner be denied the right to carry!

Bluto

Please name one legally qualified person who has been ,or will be denied their right to carry a weapon , if we have universal background checks . Really , 1000 Chardons ? Why don't you explain your logic to those victim's parents . I'm sure they will understand .

SamAdams

Only if you first explain how a universal background check would have stopped the Chardon shooter. After all, HE didn't try to buy the guns! Why not? Because he would have been turned down under the EXISTING system because he's underage!

The only way universal background checks will have any impact on the actions of crazies is if a new law will suddenly cause the bad guys to say, "Whoa! I was willing to commit mass murder, but there's NO WAY I'm gonna violate the background check requirements!" And once you agree that that's what'll happen, please give me a call because I have a bridge in New York I want to sell to you.

Bluto

Required background checks on ALL gun sales will keep people who buy them legally from selling them to people who aren't supposed to have them . And if they do then they will be subject to legal ramifications . No , the law won't stop every killing . Just because the law doesn't keep everyone from drinking and driving should we just NOT have that law ? Or , because murders keep happening even though it is illegal , then we throw the laws out ? Yes , there are laws in place , but people have got around those laws . Time to close the loopholes . Every law that exists , someone has broken ( or severely bent ) . Do we still have these laws ? Yes we do . Do we still need these laws ? Yes we do .

BW1's picture
BW1

It's already illegal to sell to someone under disability, so what changes? Do you really think people who sell to felons and nutjobs do so unknowingly?
If so, talk to Sam about that bridge for sale.

2cents's picture
2cents

Add in the elimination of violent video games & movies, automobiles, abortion and on and on and on!

lifetimeresident

Very Sad. Obviously this kid was not playing with a full deck. Not one teacher or parent seen that this kid was nuts.

Cowboy

...yeah, kinda like Super Judge!

Super Judge

hey there cowboy would you like to meet up somewhere face to face and have a little chit chat? I'll even buy you lunch and we can sit down real civil like in have a good time. anytime you wanna quit hiding behind a keyboard of yours and have a good time let me know.

Super Judge

in fact I'd like to see all of the regular bloggers get together and meet face to face I think it would be interesting

Julie R.

I think it would be interesting, too. I'm still wondering who that attorney that called itself Buff was!

Bluto

That's a great idea , just make sure we all bring our guns , because that's the NRA's solution to everything . More guns . On the bright side , there would be a lot less bloggers after that little get together ; P ))))

Cowboy

I don't leave home without it!

Super Judge

So then I take it you're in, name the time and place.

BlueAngel

I loved it when the one mother told him "he should be lucky that there is all these police officers in this courtroom".... I am not sure it would have stopped me tho.. He is repulsive.. not a sorry bone in his body.. and the T-shirt he wore... I still think he should have gotten death tho...

doc5798a

Sorry to advise you Ladydye, he has all the same rights as an adult. What the hell you trying to say that now the Bill of Rights has an age requirement built in it. And. Are you sure the laws are not bring enforced? What are your sources that you base your comments on.

KURTje

We the people need by law to have him dead quickly (less than a year). To house him is unfair to the ones whose lives he negatively impacted.

Fireside

I'm telling ya...we need a "Black Dolphin" system starting at the juvy detention center.

sorryhog

Why pay to feed and house this idiot?

SamAdams

Prison was intended primarily for one purpose: To rehabilitate those sent there. The obvious bonus is that those imprisoned aren't able to victimize any more innocents while they're there.

This kid will never, EVER get out of prison. And judging from what he did coupled with how he behaved in court, he will never, EVER be rehabilitated. Under those terms, it might be time to revisit the notion that juveniles can't be sentenced to death! In extreme cases — and I don't think anyone will argue that this isn't one — it would save a great deal of money and grief if we just cut to the chase and put a needle in the boy's arm!

And for the record, I'm betting the expenses involved in keeping him locked up indefinitely are even higher than food and shelter. Does anybody think that he's going to be part of the mainstream prison population, at least in his first years behind bars? I tend to doubt it. After all, look what happened to Jeffrey Dahmer in jail!

Cowboy

Oh I believe he will be rehabilitated, BUT he will be rehabilitated at Bubba's rate!

Cowboy

...or Super Judge!

Julie R.

I'll bet if anybody ever did any research on the filthy thing that kid said, he got it from some book or a movie.

I agree with the comment about not one teacher or parent seeing how nuts this kid was. The news has now reported that he sent a text to his sister two weeks before the shooting about taking a gun to school. If that's true, how pathetic that this whole tragedy might have been prevented.

Bluto

IMO , He was probably an avid poster of comments on the Register . Let see , anyone not been on since his arrest ? ; ))))))))))))

buckeye15

Let's see...Taxpayer, origen, Sam...probably a few others.

44846GWP

Winnie?

BW1's picture
BW1

What's weird is he requested a new court appointed attorney to file an appeal shortly after his outburst. Maybe he's trying for another bite at the insanity plea apple.

pavedparadise

Time to bring back the wild wild west. Hang him at high noon

doctorsRdrugdealers

He will go in a virgin but he wont die a virgin. after Lucasville send him to Lancaster were he can tie that shirt in a knot and put on some purple cool aid on his face! you can find him in the last bathroom stall between 3-5 in the morning!! working! lol

Just Saying

Tax payer support for the next 75 years ! How nice.