Handicapping the Oscars, Pt. 2

Jason Singer
Mar 23, 2010


Last week, we examined the Best Director race. Today, we'll look at the Best Supporting Actor category:

Michael Sheen ("Frost/Nixon"): In his last two movies, this British actor has played second-fiddle to Helen Mirren ("The Queen") and now Frank Lagella, who will almost certainly get a Best Actor nomination for his portrayal of Richard Nixon. In both movies, Sheen has outshone the supposed superstars he has been paired with.

Heath Ledger ("The Dark Knight"): The sentimental favorite. Ledger died before the movie was ever released, but his performance sparked TDK's $1 billion in revenues. Simply one of the greatest villains in movie history.

Josh Brolin ("Milk"): Where did this guy come from? He's been in so many great movies the last few years ("No Country for Old Men," "W.," "In the Valley of Elah," "American Gangster."). Add another to the list.

James Franco ("Milk"): Already received a bunch of accolades for this performance. Perfectly plays Milk's boyfriend, who clearly signed up for a long-term relationship but not necessarily a revolution.

John Malkovich ("The Changeling"): The Academy loves him, and he gives the best performance ever by an atheist actor portraying a crusading, Christian preacher.

Other notables: Robert Downey Jr. ("Tropic Thunder"), Tom Cruise ("Tropic Thunder"), Michael Kelly ("The Changeling"), Phillip Seymour Hoffman ("Doubt") and Ralph Fiennes ("The Reader").

My favorite: Josh Brolin. His performance as Milk's murderer is subtle, nuanced and altogether a show-stealer.

My pick to win: James Franco. He seems to be garnering more attention than Brolin, and I expect "Milk" to have a big Oscar night.



I hate to say it but I did like Cruise in Tropic Thunder. I would not bring myself to admit it was him....I was in a deep state of denial, but finally the credits proved me wrong and the wife was right about something (hey there is a first time for everything).

I think the award for gayest scene ever should go to the him for the volleyball scene in Top Gun. That was gayer than the beging to the video for "Relax" by Frankie Goes To Hollywood.

Robert Downey Jr. was pretty good as well, but not as good as Cruise.


i hope mentioning tropic thunder winning oscars was a joke


Dear Reader,

No, I wasn't joking. While it won't be winning any Oscars, which is what you asked about, both Cruise & Downey Jr. did receive Golden Globe nominations for their performances, which probably means the Academy will consider nominating them also. However, I can guarantee they won't win anything with the strong competition in this category.



tom cruise just was not funny in that movie, the movie itself was alright, but no where near oscar worthy...

i didnt know that cruise won a golden globe for that... hopefully it was for worst cameo of the year or something