Yost arrested on theft charges

Property owner accused of taking tenants’ money but not paying the bills
Shawn Foucher
Oct 12, 2013


Accused scheister Joe Yost was in the county jail for a grand total of two hours Friday night.

It was a quick taste of what may lie in store for him, if he’s ultimately convicted of felony theft charges for allegedly bilking his former mobile home park tenants out of thousands of dollars.

An Erie County grand jury recently indicted Yost, 66, on two counts of fifth-degree felony theft. Erie County deputies tightened up the loose ends on the secret indictment Friday afternoon, asking Catawba Island police to arrest Yost at a home in the 4200 block of E. Trail St.

Police said they arrested him without incident and handed him off to deputies in a meet-up at the Bay View fire station. He was promptly booked into the Erie County jail, although within about two hours he secured a bondsman to post $10,000 bond, jail guards said.

Investigators and prosecutors settled on the two low-level felonies because only a few of the former tenants of Hoppers mobile home park could provide financial records to support their allegations against Yost.

Through his company Westgate Development, Yost owns the Hoppers mobile home park property at Venice Road and Tiffin Avenue.

He’s accused of collecting money from Hoppers tenants for water services, but failing to pay the city for those services. The situation festered for years — from about 2008 to 2013 — until this past summer, when city officials moved to shut off the water service.

Yost is about $260,000 delinquent on the water and sewer bills at the Hoppers property, city officials said.

When the city killed the property’s water service, it effectively displaced dozens of people who had lived at the mobile home park for years. Almost all those people have since scattered to the wind.    

Meanwhile, while the tenants were being ousted, Sandusky detectives began investigating Yost for collecting the water money but failing to pay the city. Their findings culminated in the grand jury indictment and Friday’s arrest.

“The victims are the tenants of Hoppers trailer court, who were paying rent and water bills to Mr. Yost,” Sandusky police Detective Dave West said. “Then, Mr. Yost was not paying the water bill at all. But he was taking money from the tenants.”

Many of the former tenants couldn’t provide financial records detailing their payments to Yost. The two theft charges represent just two tenants who could provide documentation showing they paid more than $1,000 to Yost, but less than $7,500. West said the names of the two tenants weren’t immediately available.

“The challenge with the whole thing was (finding) accurate and detailed records,” West said.

Medina County prosecutor Dean Holman was appointed as the special prosecutor in the case. Erie County prosecutor Kevin Baxter bowed out because of a conflict of interest.



First thing I seen when I got my hard copy this morning.


Maybe Sandusky should check all the landlords out. So it doesn't happened again.


Great way to start my day! This dude owes me money, I'll never see.

Kharma, Joe, Kharma, coming after ya.

fewdss's picture

Start working at home with Google! Its by-far the best job Ive had. Last Wednesday I got a brand new BMW since getting a check for $6474. I began this 8-months ago and immediately was bringing home at least $77 per hour. Useful Reference http://ow.ly/pAu07


It's about time! Good deal!

Home Boy

The low of the lowest.


did you mean the lowest of the low?

Home Boy

Yes, Reading Signs. Thank you>


That's what those sirens were for yesterday, lol. Never hear them up here.

Darwin's choice

Yost and Baxter......now there's a couple of CON'S for sure..!!!


What did he use as collateral to pay the bond? Couldn't the city seize whatever he used as collateral to pay his back taxes?


The first collar flip I've ever seen in a mugshot ....congrats !


Don Johnson made that sooo cool in the eighties. But poor Joe just isn't pulling it off.


I recall David Soul pulling that look off in the '70's ahhh.. David and Don - both were so hot!

Poor Joe, oh so not!


Julie R.

Why did Baxter bow out because of a conflict of interest? What's the conflict? As for Dean Holman ---- why does Baxter always bring HIM in?

The Answer Person

Take it all and see how he likes it. One would think his mother with all her money would step up to the plate and help her poor little Joey.


"As for Dean Holman ---- why does Baxter always bring HIM in?"

For desired results. Holman's decision will be Baxter's decision.


This is soooooooooo long overdue!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Oh, I'm sure that good ole Deana will offer his pal diversion. So, no need to worry folks this case will be fixed!

dorothy gale

Boy, he sure looks smug. Everything he owns should be siezed to pay what he owes. What a lowlife.


I can gaurentee that he doesn't get prison time for a felony 5.... I would be shocked if he even gets county time. 30 days Max. But more than likely he will get probation and have to try ti attempt to re pay some of the money that they can prove he stole, which doesn't appear to be very much. The city can send the bill to collections and he wont be able to get any water turned on in his name..WOW, that just doesn't seem right. He has con 'd so much money and there isn't really crape they can do about it....


That's why he has that smug look. This guy is worst than a thug that actually robs you!


Its kinda funny, the water department would cut your water off in two months time if you were a homeowner and hadnt paid the bill. Shame on the water department for letting this go for so long. I think thye faut the system all themselves as well....


These people probably paid in cash and didn't keep records but why isn't the word of dozens of people good?


Better yet, did Sandusky PD seize Yost's records? Based on the article it appears the PD relied only on paper work from the residents.


Someone should be able to come up with at least one of Yost's lease agreements, that says the water is included in the monthly lease payment.


I have a different slant on things; and that is, where was the city when all this was going on for five years? The city has yet to come up with an explanation of why they left the water running. The city caused their own problems by not addressing the overdue water bill, plus, the county could have taken addressed the delinquent taxes and done something with the situation a lot sooner then they did. Both entities caused a great deal of hardship that didn't have to happen. It all could have been handled a lot differently before Yost even filed bankruptcy locking everything up for years. Does anyone know how long bankruptcy lasts? Seem like it has been going on for years.


All part of the bigger plan.


So exactly what is the conflict of interest in the Erie County prosecutor taking on this case? I'd like to know exactly why Baxter had to "bow out" of this case. Is he a partner of this guy? Did he represent him in another case? What's going on here?


It may be that they know each other from growing up on the Cedar Point Chaussee.


What did Ed Widman, the then city treasurer know and when did he know it? Have to wonder if there aren't charges of malfeasance are not proper.


Good point.


Bad enough people have to live in a trailer park then the low life owner steals from the tenants.Hope he has to sell his home in Catawba.Now his membership at the yacht club is in trouble.Bet the boys in jail were impress with his shirt.


At times, I will look back at public records that may precede an incident such as reported on this news story.

I have had links to public records online only to find out that the records were removed. It is a good idea to make a copy of a public record to make sure that nobody has went back and tampered with the public record, edited what was written or simply made the record disappear as if the record never existed.

2913.42 Tampering with records.
(1) Falsify, destroy, remove, conceal, alter, deface, or mutilate any writing, computer software, data, or record;

I will come back to this story as my time permits and post a link to a public record that is a few years old. Be prepared to make a copy of the public record just in case somebody decides to tamper with it. There is a reason why Ohio has a law against the tampering with records.


Sad to day, it's renter BEWARE ( whether premises or land ). Tenants should be able to get bank print outs of their cancelled checks, and in the future it would behoove people to check the water department to make sure their landlord (slum or no) is paying.

An ounce of prevention, perhaps? Since you really can't trust people anymore.

Kottage Kat

I staple my MO receipt to a copy of my rent bill. In April they shut off our water because the landlord I & R Properties did not pay the water bill.
Something is wrong there
I smell a RAT


Kat, It's a good thing you've got records. Imagine how many people don't keep that stuff. When I paid the water bill where I rented - because that was the agreement - ( I kept it up and kept all bill stubs and receipt). If the landlord pays it and they go into arrears, yes, they should get the law on their tail right away.

You're right, something is fishy with that Property owner. Did you check the auditor's site and see if they are behind on their property taxes?


"Yost is about $260,000 delinquent on the water and sewer bills at the Hoppers property, city officials said." Where do they think the money would have come from if he owes for the Trailer Park? The people paid their money and got screwed now he should be charged legally for all of that not just what financial records found. He charged them, they paid, and now they are without a home. Fix him good since he screwed over the people who trusted him for a place to live.


The State had and has the power to subpoena Yost's bank records if they really wanted to prove he took the money from the renters for water and didn't pay the water bill. In other words it would be easy to prove a $250,000 racketeering case if the State were motivated to do so. It's ridiculous that the victims are being asked to build the State's case because of Mr. Yost's friendship with Mr. Baxter.


Centauri: Do you think anyone cares about laws anymore especially when it comes to shredding?


Mr. Baxter should disclose the nature of the conflict of interest and produce the contract with Mr. Holman approved by the County Commissioners.

It is illegal for Baxter to appoint a special prosecutor and it is illegal to use another county's full time prosecutor. How is Mr. Holman and Medina County being paid for his services? Is he working for Erie County on Medina County time.

How does he have jurisdiction in view of the fact that a county prosecutor only has jurisdiction in his county where he has filed an oath of office and posted bond? Did the Erie County Commissioners approve of the hiring of Mr. Holman as is required by the ORC? What judge approved Dean Holman and di he swear him in and make him post the bond of office?
Is Erie County going to pay Medina County for the use of the county's full time prosecutor?

Finally, the man has been engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity for many years and the best they can come up with are some low level felonies? In my opinion this case should be referred to special prosecutors in the AG's office to eliminate the appearance of impropriety instead of Baxter's associate who is brought in to cover his political favors


When this case first came up, Mr. Baxter said he was calling in a special prosecutor because he knew Mr. Yost. Seems to me that was the ethical thing to do. Sometimes a special prosecutor is brought in. It certainly isn't unheard of. Mr. Baxter has also gone out of this county to serve as a special prosecutor. Just keep up with the news and don't try to make a federal case out of everything.

Julie R.

tk: BULL.


Exactly my point TK. Mr. Baxter called in a special prosecutor of his choice to prosecute his friend Mr. Yost. That's improper for a number of reasons.

First, Mr. Baxter does not have the authority under law to pick or assign a special prosecutor. That power is with the Commissioners of the County NOT the prosecutor. The fact that he usurped power illegally to help out a friend makes this illegal and unethical.

Second, a special prosecutor can not be employed full time by another county as is the case with Mr. Holman because he is committing theft in office by spending his time and Medina County resources on an Erie County case. As an example Perkins PD Chief cannot abandon his duties to fill in as Sandusky Chief. Again, Mr. Baxter is aidding and abetting theft in office and illegal activity by this appointment.

Third, just because this assignment occurred before and Mr. Baxter has also done it doesn't mean it is legal. In fact Mr. Baxter, Mr. Holman and Mr. Bill Mason (former Cuyahoga County prosecutor) all democrats have unlawfully traded off political cases for years. In my opinion it is how they fix cases for their friends or target their enemies. Mr. Yost is clearly undercharged and questions as to how he got away with it for so many years (role of Don Icsman, and Baxter in protecting him) need to be answered.

The appointment of Holman is illegal under Ohio and US law and it is a federal corruption case waiting to happen. It is a text book example of how criminal cases are under investigated and under prosecuted for friends of those in the political ruling class. Add this case to the Sandusky Housing grant scandal (also on Icsman's watch) and it very worthy of federal investigation and prosecution.

The Answer Person

Maybe we need a local "MOST HATED" list? Any suggestions for candidates?


Good idea, I suggest different categories. Easier to find


Yost enjoyed deceiving everyone , even the city, those with very little income to people wanting new housing . Stand up and be a man, own up to your bad business practices . You are a citizen of a wonderful country, why do you do these things? Yo mama spank you too much as a kid? or what?


Where is the outrage of the City not shutting off the water for FIVE YEARS and allowing a quarter of a MILLION DOLLARS not to be paid?

Again, why no investigation?
The State should be brought in to DIG DEEP into the City and see if they didn't allow this to happen so they can take the property!

I consider the City as being bigger crooks than Yost! Where was iceman during all this, oh that's right, he was hiding in his office, hoping not to be found during Sandusky's Police Chiefs trials.


Don't forget Icsman was missing in action for the Housing Grant scandal as well. The Nuesse case was designed as a distraction so the on going corrupt activity (that she would have exposed) could continue.

This case is a great example of those who are "friends" with government lawyers such as Icsman and Baxter can get away with illegal activity for years. It's part of the the play to pay system that was partially dismantled by the Feds in Cuyahoga County but needs to be addressed in Erie County.


I bet the IRS would love to audit him.

This started in '08 ? This should have been rectified no later than mid year of '09.

So whose palm was he greasing to look the other way?



does anyone know if this is the Yost who was in the SHS class of '64? This act was deliberate and deserves to be punished to the full extent of the law. Then put him in a property with no water and see how he likes it!

Darwin's choice

Was he involved in an accident that someone was killed in back then?


Why doesn't the City of Sandusky charge him? He stole the water by not paying the bill. The bill was in his name, not the individual tenants


Nice shirt collar.


Is he still in the county jail? According to what I just heard on the scanner he is. Interesting??



It looks to me like his property valuation increased about 300% in 2006 and stayed the same for 2012. It was a change by the BOR.

$450,000 2004 Sale Price
$107,500 1999 Sale Price

$66,214.13 Delinquency
$197,787.71 Special Assessments
$18,157.99 Penalty/Interest

$106,852.85 Charge
$32,338.17 Penalty/Interest

$180,000 2005 Sale Price
$26,237.96 Delinquency
$6,948.13 Penalty/Interest
$195.31 Special Assessments

$101.88 Charge
$22.63 Penalty/Interest

LLC like that Island Rocket Ferry that owed about $200,000 in back taxes?


The Island Express Boatlines LLC did owe over $200,000 in back property taxes but never filed for Bankruptcy like Mr. Yost. The LLC major member was Erie County Prosecutor Kevin Baxter who owned about 30% of the business.

The company asked for and obtained numerous government loans and grants and at least one business loan from Citizens Bank. While members are not liable for the LLC debts they are liable if they are asked to guarantee a business loan which Island Express LLC members did with Citizens Bank.

Thus, when the company got into trouble it avoided filing bankruptcy where government agencies would have a priority interest in the assets i.e the boats. Instead using political connections Baxter and associates asked the state, county and city to not pursue or delay their claims so that Citizens Bank would be paid with the sale of the Boats and they would not be personally liable on the bank loan. After there was nothing left, the County treasurer wrote off the $200,000 on advice of a special prosecutor Baxter personally selected.

End result: By using political influence Baxter was able to have Citizens Bank receive a preferential payment on its loan, avoid personal liability for the debt and hose the State of Ohio and Erie County for taxes and the security interest the State had in the Boat obtained by federal grant money.

By the way I understand former members of Island Express LLC now enjoy ownership in a yacht.


Thank you for your comments as they speak the truth. I had links to many Ohio public documents but they no longer work. Ohio is a very corrupt state and destroying public documents is par with corrupt Ohio. I have followed this Island Express Ferry company all the way to Florida. One of the owners came back to Ohio and is now running a "Wealth Management" company in Ohio. I have a lot of information on this person but cannot post it here. At one time, I was active getting in touch with the Sandusky Register bloggers who posted comments here. Since the SR upgraded their online site, I do not have the option of contacting you by private message (PM). Thank you for the additional information about that yacht. Keep your comments coming as I do follow them.

I have additional links about that Island Express Ferry but I do not want to post them here. The SR moderators might delete them for being off topic or some other reason. Maybe a future Sandusky Register news story will be more appropriate.


Yes, this individual was named by State officials as "manipulating" grant submission data for the boat grants. He allegedly has an interest in the Yacht along with another former Island Express member initials JF.

Wealth management? Perhaps he helps manage commercial laundries? This Yost case maybe useful in requesting the AG establish a task force with a special prosecutor under 177.01 as there is a pattern. Also understand Mr. Nickles of the PAC seriously objected to Island Express dealings years ago and Icsman didn't care.

Julie R.

Citizens Bank was involved with that shady ferry boat business and received a preferential payment on its loan?

Citizens Bank sure does seem to be involved in a lot of cases in Erie County. Weren't they involved in the Krista Harris case, the lady that got a harsh five-year prison sentence after the clowns at the courthouse (via a special prosecutor and a rent-a-judge) claimed she stole from her elderly aunt even after the aunt's doctor testified that the power of attorney she used was legal ~ prepared years back when the aunt was still competent?

Wasn't it also Citizens Bank that foreclosed on a factory back in 2001 or 2002, was in and out of the factory for years removing things, yet after the factory owner died they filed a lawsuit saying the man's estate should have to pay to have the oil drums removed? Didn't Binette rule in favor of Citizens Bank and their attorney (a McGookey) but the 6th District Court of Appeals (surprise, surprise) didn't agree and told Binette to review the case again?

Wasn't the "$3 Million Dollar Mystery Account" that the former Clerk of Court Barb Johnson got blamed for at CITIZENS BANK ~ the mystery account that the county claimed nobody knew about but Barb Johnson? (I know for a fact that's a lie)

Didn't the Journal report that the employee in the Erie County Treasurer's office ~ the one that only got 2 years for stealing $150K of taxpayer monies and didn't even have to serve that ~ worked at Citizens Bank in Sandusky, Ohio before landing the job with the county?

I also heard about another case recently involving people from Huron. It was a probate case and it involved attorneys, Citizens Bank and a 92-year-old woman before her death. (guess who won?)

I know another bank in Erie County (in Huron, Ohio) ~ main headquarters corrupt Cleveland, Ohio ~ that sure is in the back pocket of somebody up at that corrupt Eeeerie County courthouse, too. Unreal the criminal acts that dirty bank got away with.


The Federal RICO statute was originally intended to pursue corrupt activity involving organized crime or AKA the "Mob". The Feds had so much success with it that they effectively dismantled old time organized crime.

An FBI agent involved in the original prosecutions in Cleveland employing RICO to attack organized crime in large metropolitan areas like Cleveland explained that the success of RICO led organized crime to relocate to areas like Ottawa and Erie Counties and developed a new hybrid involving companies and government officials what some call GOB (Government officials, Organized Corrupt activity, Business/Bar)

GOB prospers in environments where: 1) Law enforcement, justice, and political infrastructures are easy to co-opt; 2) small media market including a newspaper which is easily controlled; and, 3) small bank or banks which are easily controlled. The system protects itself by ensuring members are placed in agencies that have the ability to investigate allegations of corruption or misconduct such as Bar Associations, Police Departments, Prosecutors offices etc. You'll see bogus prosecutions to eliminate honest persons that pose a threat to the system.

The result is one cannot complain to authorities, obtain an investigation or publicize the issue because the system is interlocked and codependent. At some point it may become so obvious as in Cuyahoga County, that a prosecution is launched and some members are sacrificed but the larger system remains in place. For example, the Plain Dealer has never called for investigation of the eight other judges named by Frank Russo as allegedly involved in corrupt activity.

If one examines the Board of Directors for Citizens Bank, and major shareholders there will likely be a lot of interconnections with elected officials, attorneys/law firms, and major corporate players including a media company.


It is possible that Yost's financial problems may be due to high property tax valuations, high taxes and the decisions of those in Sandusky (OHIO) city government. Notice that I did say possible. I am still looking for public documents.

$350,000 2/9/2005 Sale Price Buyer: HAYES AVENUE DEVELOPMENT (Yost)
$1,461,750 2006/01/01 Valuation

How does property bought for $350,000 (2/9/2005) jump to $1,461,750 (1/1/2006)? After a BOR hearing, the valuation dropped to $385,540.

Property was sold to BORN AGAIN SALVAGE LLC for $51,000 (6/8/2012)

"Sandusky to demolish former American Crayon Building"

(Published: 9/27/2008)
"SANDUSKY The owner of the former Dixon Ticonderoga crayon factory has filed for protection from creditors in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Toledo."

"Hayes Avenue Development Co. LLC is one of three firms linked to Sandusky developer Joseph Yost III that is seeking to reorganize under Chapter 11 of the bankruptcy code. The largest of the firms, Westgate Properties Ltd., listed between $1 million and $10 million in debt. The firm owns a Sandusky shopping center, according to Jonathan Blakely, an Akron attorney who represents the businesses."


Scheister. That's a great name for him. Does he vote?

God Of Thunder

I still think that his Yost's office manager, Tami Rapp should be checked out as well. How can you NOT know what was going on. Money coming in and nothing going out huh.. If that's the way a business is run, then I want in.

Julie R.



How come he can post a bond for bail but not pay his bills. I think he ought to stay in the clink until the over due bills are paid.