Violent crime gets double time

Man who pleaded guilty to 2012 home invasion receives twice the prison time he expected
Courtney Astolfi
Mar 1, 2014
A Sandusky man received double the amount of prison time he was expecting during a sentencing hearing Thursday for a violent 2012 home invasion.
Takye Fenderson, now 23, 2000 block Foxborough Circle, will serve 12 years for the crimes.

In October 2012, Fenderson was one of three men who stormed a Perry Street home in what police believe was an attempted robbery.

Inside was Robert Garrett, 67. The men brutally beat Garrett, throwing him through a glass door and yanking away his phone as he tried to call 911.

Fenderson was hit with a slew of charges, and was ultimately indicted on 27 counts — most of which were felonies, according to court documents.

He chose to take a plea deal in September, agreeing to plead guilty to two counts complicity to commit aggravated robbery, documents stated.

As part of that plea, prosecutors told Fenderson he would receive six years in prison, his attorney, Jack Bradley, argued Thursday in court.

Erie County Common Pleas Court Judge Tygh Tone said he was not beholden to that agreement.

Bradley contended it was incumbent upon Tone to make it clear during earlier hearings that Fenderson may receive a lengthier sentence.

“If you want to withdraw your plea, you can,” Tone responded, saying Bradley could opt for a jury trial if he preferred.

Tone cited Garrett’s testimony before the court, which detailed the violent attack he sustained at the hands of Fenderson and his cohorts.

“I’ve lived on Perry Street for 46 years and never had a break-in,” Garrett later told the Register.

He pointed to his right eye, which he lost as a result of the attack. “Now it’s gone” Garrett said.

But during a statement in his own defense, Fenderson argued for leniency.

“Everyone makes mistakes,” he said. “I’m not an angel, but I’m far from a bad person”

In the end, Tone sentenced Fenderson to 12 years. Bradley immediately asked for Tone to appoint an appeals attorney to the case — indicating Fenderson’s intention to fight the sentence.

Fenderson began to argue with Tone’s decision, with the judge cutting him off and ordering deputies to handcuff him.

As they escorted him from the room, he dropped a string of profanities. “I’m young as (expletive), that’s crazy man” Fenderson said.



Maybe he could get a reduced sentence , if he gave up one of his eyes.


He has no clue what is going to happen to him in the next 12 years of his life if he makes it that far. The boys are going to have fun with him!!


I was one of takeye's boxing coaches and he didn't come from a bad home. He was pretty good in boxing he might of had a future. Bobbie's son is one of my close friends and I know bobby owns quite a few guns. If only he could of got to one.


I never said the schools should raise our children I just said they should teach mindfulness. Schools have our kids 6hrs ,180 days per year for 12 years. That 12960 hrs. That's like a full time job for 6 yrs. that a big impact. I know a guy who did 9 1/2 yrs and he is a very good man (Q) and he is a contributing member if society. Let's hope he rises above the rest and proves the statistics wrong.


no sympathy here. he should have gotten more time. crying because he's so young? yeah, that's why. running around beating up on older people. he should be locked up until he is as old as his victim is now. then maybe consider parole, but don't even ask about it until then..

4-wheeler al

just a bad seed. Its a shame they rather live on the street and get a job.


Thank you judge Tone well done. You are helping make this community a safe place, let the criminal scum that are "far from a bad guy" realize there is a price for their criminal cruelty.


When criminals hire Jack Bradley from Lorain, it pretty much admits their guilt... Look him up and see all the winners he has been hired to represent, sadly he usually wins and brags about it after.


You are advised that the judge does not have to honor the plea deal made with a prosecutor. There is more this kid done that we are not reading off. This is why Tone did what he did. 99 percent of the time the Judge honors a plea deal. Good job Tone because that's all Baxter knows how to do is plea deal.


I agree with you. The nature of the crime merited more than the six years Baxter offered, and Tone was right to give him more time. Baxter has a track record of not taking violent crimes including rapes and felonious assaults seriously by his willingness to offer generous plea deals on these types of offences.


Clean this town up Mr. Judge Tone....Is's about time to make change and hold these thugs accountable for their actions.

If he had a father period and some punk like him beat on him how would he fill about this BS?

Hope he never makes it out!!!!!


If Obama had a son.........

Stop It



Miss momma if only your kids had a dad. Instead of two moms.


Cocoa butter


This is sad, Takye. You needed money so bad you did a home invasion? On a 67 year old guy? Beating him up? Throwing him through a glass door? Taking his sight? A guy busts his butt his whole life to make it to 67 and you beat the hell out of him. Is that the real you, Takye?


It Truly should have been AN EYE for an EYE ... his right one.

I see, in the not so distance future, where these home invaders are going to get taken out - by the people whom they prey on. That's really what these thugs and punks are; are predators, just a different kind.

Julie R.

Now that I think about it, Baxter was willing to give this punk only six years for brutally beating an elderly man and blinding him? That punk should have been given 20 years at the very least! What's with Baxter, anyway? Here's to hoping that Tone made it clear that he didn't have to abide by that ludicrous plea agreement because I sure would hate to see the little punk win his appeal!

Julie R.

Baxter (via a special prosecutor and a special rent-a-judge) gave that Krista Harris lady FIVE YEARS for theft from her elderly aunt, even after the aunt's doctor testified that the POA Harris used was prepared years back when the elderly aunt was still very much competent ----- yet Baxter then offers this punk a plea deal and only SIX YEARS for what he did?


Also, don't forget the three years Officer Fitzpatrick received for sexually assaulting a 15 year old girl in a police station while handcuffed! He got out after 11 months on early release courtesy of a special prosecutor and visiting retired judge.

Then there was the three years given to James Hofmann, former publisher of this newspaper for sexually abusing a 10 year old boy. He was never prosecuted for the 8 year old girl he molested courtesy of Special prosecutor and retired visiting judge picked by Baxter.

And what about old Erie County Commissioner Butcher stalking teen age black girls for sex while drunk? He got 30 days house arrest courtesy of a special prosecutor and retired visiting judge picked by Baxter and Butcher thanked him by approving Baxter's legal fess for his private company. The same special prosecutor was then used to go after Baumgartner for fleeing and eluding after an attempt to arrest for a misdemeanor probation violation without a warrant.

Finally, there was Judge Binette's pervert brother who liked to sexually exploit teenage girls. Seventeen months for him courtesy of a special prosecutor and retired judge picked by Baxter.

Yes, it's pretty obvious that Baxter identifies with violent punks and sex abusers as he offers them deals while he goes after people he considers threats to his livelihood or reputation.


That is an excellent article, rgt. Thanks for posting the link!


I agree with starryeyes83. Sooner or later -- probably sooner -- some idiot is going to get killed in one of these home invasions. It won't matter if he's "young as #@*!" and it won't matter if somebody thinks the "sentence" is "crazy." NOTHING matters once you're dead!

There are quite literally millions of cases in this country every year where a law-abiding homeowner defends himself or herself with a gun. The vast majority don't result in death, but COULD have. Maybe if the mainstream media would spend more time publishing those stories and less time lobbying for gun control via thankfully rare workplace or classroom shootings, a few more thugs would get it through their thick skulls that the punishment for some crimes can be a little out of proportion.

In the interim, 12 years behind bars seems perfectly IN proportion to me! The homeowner was badly hurt, and the punishment for such a crime ought to hurt, too. Congratulations, dumba$$. Guess the home invasion is a whole lot less amusing to you NOW! Want another newsflash? It was never funny or cool to most of us in the first place!


I googled Kevin Baxter and this is what I found. Lol!!!