Official: NY undercover cop present at bike rally

Officer may have witnessed violent confrontation that reportedly left one man with stitches and another with a broken spine and legs
Associated Press
Oct 6, 2013

Authorities are investigating whether an undercover police officer present at a motorcycle rally witnessed a violent confrontation between an SUV driver and a swarm of bikers and didn't immediately report it, a law enforcement official said Saturday.

The officer came forward several days after the Sept. 29 rally to say he was present, according to the official, who was not authorized to speak publicly about the investigation and spoke to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity. The officer has an attorney, and internal affairs detectives are trying to determine whether he witnessed the assault on the SUV driver, the official said.

New York Police Department spokesman John McCarthy said a detective had been stripped of his gun and badge pending the outcome of an internal affairs investigation.

McCarthy said internal affairs was investigating the case and looking into whether any off-duty officers may have been present.

Undercover officers are required to immediately report being a witness to a crime. Uniformed officers are required to take police action if they see a crime occurring, but the rules are murkier for undercover officers who face blowing their cover, confusing civilians who don't realize the undercover is really a cop and ruining yearslong investigations.

For example, Gescard Isnora, an undercover officer involved in the fatal police shooting of an unarmed man after his bachelor party in 2006, stepped out of his role and fired a shot as officers opened fire on Sean Bell and his friends. Isnora was fired and lost his pension after a departmental trial ruling that he should not have shot his weapon while undercover.

Last weekend, dozens of bikers stopped the Range Rover SUV on a highway, attacked the vehicle, then chased the driver and pulled him from the car after he plowed over a motorcyclist while trying to escape, police said. The driver, Alexian Lien, needed stiches after being pummeled by the bikers.

The motorcyclist who was crushed by the SUV, Edwin Mieses Jr., of Lawrence, Mass., suffered a broken spine and two broken legs and may never walk again, his family said.

Some of the encounter was captured on a camera mounted on the helmet of one of the bikers and was posted online. Investigators have been interviewing dozens of bikers and witnesses, but it still remains unclear how many people attacked Lien. On Saturday, police said two other motorcyclists were taken into custody and released a photograph of another man they say they want to question in connection with the attack.

Robert Sims, 35, of Brooklyn, was arraigned Saturday in Manhattan on charges of first-degree gang assault, first-degree assault and third-degree criminal possession of a weapon. Bail was set at $100,000.

An attorney for the 35-year-old Sims did not immediately return a call for comment. There was no listed telephone number for Sims at the address where police said he lived. Police have said he took part in the attack on Lien.

He is the third person to face formal charges in connection with the attack, though the case against one of those motorcyclists was subsequently dismissed when prosecutors said they needed more time to investigate.

Police also detained another Brooklyn man Friday who they believed had participated in the attack. As of Saturday, formal charges had not been filed, authorities said.

Lien has not been charged. His wife said in a statement this week they feared for their lives as they drove off.

Mieses' family held a news conference Friday with their lawyer in which they said that he wasn't doing anything wrong when he was struck by Lien's SUV. They acknowledged that Mieses had stopped his bike in front of the family's vehicle but said he was trying to get the other riders to leave the family alone when he was hit.

 

Comments

shucks

"Last weekend, dozens of bikers stopped the Range Rover SUV on a highway, attacked the vehicle, then chased the driver and pulled him from the car after he plowed over a motorcyclist while trying to escape, .."

...............What I want to know is --Why did the bikers stop and attack the SUV in the first place ?

No Wake

Do you mean the first time, the second time or the third time? The Range Rover initially stopped after hitting a bike that brake checked him on the expressway.

2cents

Right, why did he break check him is what I want to know???

Statealltheway

From what I've read (not sure how accurate it is), it is part of this bike rally for the motorcycle riders to slow down highway traffic -- motorcycles for this event routinely swarm highway traffic and slow them down for no good reason at all.

In this instance, the motorcycles slowed this SUV down, but the SUV made contact with one of the bikes, causing everyone to stop and box-in the SUV. The man in the SUV responded by gunning it and running over one of the bikes, thus leading to an extensive chase and ultimate beating of the SUV driver.

Hope that helps.

shucks

Thanks , now the article makes sense .

2cents

Thank you State, I knew it started somewhere and so it proves the bikers basically started it. Everything they did was against the law and they intimidated the poor guy and he freaked out with his wife and kid on board. It seems like a fight or flight response reaction, most typical in that situation.

Personally I would have probably seen that they were just screwing around but if some guy started busting out my window and dragging my wife out of her side there would have been a few guys on the wrong end of my firearm with full justification!

beepx22

except they were in the peoples republic of new york, where the average citizen doesn't have the right to carry a firearm