Former Cleveland Clinic nurse gets 12 years

Andrew Martin attempted to hire an ER patient as a hit man, offering $10,000 to kill a woman in a dispute over ownership of her deceased brother's home, authorities said.
Associated Press
Aug 22, 2013


A former Cleveland Clinic nurse was sentenced to 12 years in prison Wednesday for trying to hire an emergency room patient as a hit man.

Andrew Martin offered $10,000 to an ER patient to kill a woman in a dispute over ownership of her deceased brother's home, authorities said. The patient tipped off police that he had been asked by a nurse if he "ever killed anyone," investigators said.

Martin, of Bristolville, about 50 miles east of Cleveland, earlier pleaded guilty to orchestrating the murder-for-hire plot. He had faced a seven- to nine-year term under federal sentencing guidelines. He also was ordered to pay more than $83,000 in restitution.

His attorney, Edward LaRue, did not immediately return a request for comment.

Martin admitted in April to using a phone to further the plot and also pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and trying to obtain private medical records.

The woman who was targeted was not harmed and Martin was arrested in November. The Cleveland Clinic quickly parted ways with him.

Prosecutors said Martin and another man began plotting in October 2011 to take ownership of a home that had belonged to an elderly former patient at the hospital where Martin worked. The patient died in late 2010.

Martin, 23, used his position there to access the patient's medical records so the other man could claim to have had a personal relationship with him, prosecutors said. They created a fake deed and claimed ownership of the ex-patient's home, prosecutors said.

A yearlong ownership fight began in probate court. A judge eventually sided with the administrator of the former owner's estate and voided a backdated deed.

Irritated that "this 70-year-old lady ... has been trying to mess up my life," Martin approached an ER patient who "looked like a big guy," according to the federal affidavit.

"Ever hurt anyone?" Martin allegedly asked the man, whose name wasn't disclosed.

"Yes, no, maybe," the ER patient responded cautiously, according to the affidavit.

Martin pressed ahead, according to the affidavit, asking, "Ever killed anyone?"

"I shot someone in the leg once," the patient responded.

Martin offered him $10,000 to kill the woman, authorities said. He also described her and her car and provided where she lived, prosecutors said.


Julie R.

This doesn't make a bit of sense.

How did they create a fake deed without the illegal assistance of attorneys?


Easy, she wasn't legally disinherited like some people we know


Julie, if you have a copy of the deed - and it's easy enough to get a copy of one - all you have to do is re-write the new one with their information on a computer and scan it and figure a way to make it look legal if you really want to. What's that old saying - where there's a will there's a way? I guess if someone really wants to do something badly enough they can do anything they want