New at Toft's

New flavors from Venice Road
May 21, 2013


If you've had a chance to sample the additions to the Toft's lineup share your thoughts in the comments section below, or tell us which is your favorite flavor and why. 



I'd skip on the Muddy Sea Salt Slam. I've tried Peanut Butter Pretzel twice. The first time I had it, it was great but the second time the pretzels were a little soggy. Maybe the ice cream melted a bit in the container before it was served. I would like to see Toft's make a Bacon flavored ice cream. Then my life would be complete.


I don't know if this is a new flavor or not, but the Root Beer Float is really good! It is just like a root beer float. Very good!


That's my son's favorite


LOVE LOVE THEM BOTH...muddy sea salt is my favorite tho


For reasons which are a mystery, Toft's makes Spumoni Ice Cream, but refuses to sell it to local customers. I think a Congressional investigation may be in order.

Dude i Roc

Spumoni is my favorite. I've been buying it at Kroger Sandusky since Christmas. They still are selling it when it usually can be found at only at holiday time . It is Kroger brand and very good-better than other brands I have tried .


I wish they sold the melon ice cream that I had at the melon festival


To everyone, I work at Toft's. Here's a little help.
Muddy's Seat Salt Slam: Vanilla Ice Cream with a Sea Salt Caramel Swirl & Chocolate covered Peanuts.
Peanut Butter Pretzel: Peanut Butter Ice Cream with a Chocolate Fudge Swirl & Chocolate covered Pretzel Pieces.

@doratheexplorer: We do sometimes but rarely sell the Melon ice cream. The actual flavor and ingredients belongs to the Melon Fest. we only make the ice cream. We do sell it sometimes though if they have left over from the festival, they give it back to us and we sell it.

Kottage Kat

Root Beer Float
Yum Yum


Thanks for the info

My favorite is raspberry bugaboo but I want to try the sea salt one it sounds great

The Hero Zone's picture
The Hero Zone

Literally just got back to the shop from errands and went out of my way to pick up a scoop of the Sea Salt. It is quite yummy!


Do they still have tart blueberry?

JW Brewer

Northcoast Bavarian Mudslide was/always will be my favorite. Since they stopped it...

Mike Schaffer

Bring back Buck-A-Moo!!!



As faer as I am concerned , there isnt any ice cream milk or anything else that will ever comes close to the freshness of Tofts and not to metion it keeps locols working
Keep up the good work Tofts

Dude i Roc

Do they still sell black walnut ice cream?


Yum, good..Praline Pecan too...


Are these only available at Toft's or can you get them at Meijers, Walmart, etc?


Now my curiosity is all in. When I first read about the sea salt flavor my reaction was Ukk. Now I guess I need to try it.