Report shows persistence of TV violence

Primetime entertainment doesn't cut back after Newtown school shooting.
Associated Press
May 2, 2013

 

Violence, gore and gunplay were staples on prime-time television even in the most sensitive period directly following the Newtown school shooting.

A study of 392 prime-time scripted programs on broadcast networks shown during the month following Vice President Joe Biden's January meeting with entertainment industry executives on the topic revealed that 193 had some incident of violence, according to the Parents Television Council. Some are cartoonish — quite literally, with Homer strangling Bart for mouthing off on "The Simpsons" — but there is plenty of gunplay, stabbings and beat-downs.

Here's a sample of the incidents captured by the PTC between Jan. 11 and Feb. 11:

• A character on ABC's "Body of Proof" says he dreams of ripping a woman's brain out while she's still alive, but he's shot as he's about to stick a hook up her nose. Then he's pushed off a balcony and killed.

• A woman on Fox's "The Following" jams an ice pick into her eye.

• A prison riot episode of CBS' "Hawaii Five-O" includes one man trying to kill someone in a laundry room press, a man snapping someone's neck with his legs and a man injected with something that causes a violent convulsion.

• A man threatens hospital workers on NBC's "Chicago Fire" with a gun before he's disabled with a Taser.

• A gun fight on ABC's "Last Resort" is ignited by one man stabbing another in the abdomen with a screwdriver.

• A man on CBS' "Criminal Minds" is shot dead by the FBI as he tries to cut the eyelids off a gallery owner's face.

• Two characters on Fox's "Bones" wake to find a corpse hanging from the canopy above their bed, dripping blood onto them.

• An already bloody man is dragged into a warehouse on CBS' "The Mentalist," choked to death and thrown in a furnace — all witnessed by a little boy hiding in the building.

• A man writhes in pain on Fox's "Fringe" before a parasite violently bursts out of his body. He's surrounded by the bodies of others who had met the same fate.

• A scene in ABC's "Grey's Anatomy" features a woman's nightmare about sawing her leg, as blood spurts and she screams in pain.

• A gymnastics coach is stabbed several times in the groin on NBC's "Law & Order: SVU."

• A man working on a coffee cart on "The Following" is doused with gasoline and burned alive.

• On CBS' "Blue Bloods," a man aims a gun at a group of children in the park before he is shot dead.

• Even President Grant on ABC's "Scandal" gets into the act, removing an oxygen mask from a woman's face so she suffocates.

Real life has continued to intrude on television entertainment as the months go by. NBC pulled an episode of its serial killer drama "Hannibal" after the Boston Marathon bombing, as did ABC with a "Castle" episode where a character stepped on a pressure-sensitive bomb. Some Newtown parents objected to a recent "Glee" episode that depicted a school shooting.

"I think it is only going to get worse," said Dr. Victor Strasburger, pediatrics professor at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine, who has written frequently on the topic of violence in the media. He said media executives are "not willing to own up to their public health responsibilities."

TV executives are reluctant to talk about violent content, and when pressed question any link between what they air on television and aggressive behavior in real life. Schedules get shifted around when tragic events are in the news, but there's no indication they have changed the types of programs being made. Policy debates have largely overlooked the issue, focusing instead on background checks for gun owners or bans on assault weapons.

In the past, networks have disputed some of the PTC methodology. Some comedic moments are counted as violent episodes in PTC's study when they could be questioned, like a play swordfight on "The Cleveland Show." The PTC doesn't detail the one violent incident it counted on Betty White's "Off Their Rockers," but it's hard to imagine comparing it to the serial killer on "The Following."

"I've had a hard time finding these studies to be very useful to parents or anyone who is looking at this objectively," said Jim Dyke, executive director of TV Watch, a Washington-based advocacy group that opposes government involvement in television programming.

Still, it's a sobering body count.

The parents' group said it found not only an increase in gore from other studies it has conducted over 18 years but a greater specificity and darkness to the violence.

"There has been no accountability, in my opinion, in terms of the degree and amount of violence," said Tim Winter, the parents' group president.

Broadcast networks find themselves squeezed by cable networks that are able to be more explicit in what they show; Dyke, in fact, said it is unfair for a group like the PTC to study broadcast violence and not include what's on cable. There's also a feeling that they're giving viewers what they want. The explosive popularity of AMC's "The Walking Dead" among young viewers has clearly made broadcasters take notice.

Talking about the gore involved in "The Following" shortly before it went on the air this winter, Fox entertainment chief Kevin Reilly said nightmarish scenarios are part of the entertainment menu that a broadcast network needs to provide to its viewers. When a network does this, it must be able to compete with smaller network on an intensity level, he said.

Parents also have the ability to block out programming that they do not want to keep it from their children, the networks' defenders said.

A CBS representative declined comment on the PTC study, while ABC, NBC and Fox did not respond to a request for comment.

"Networks are out to make money and will do whatever it takes to make money," Strasburger said. "When the public health of children comes into conflict with big money, big money always wins."

May represents a turning point for networks, which announce their fall schedules to advertisers in a couple of weeks. The four biggest networks ordered pilots for a total of 44 prospective dramas that they are considering airing sometime in the next season.

Some of them suggest the same issues will persist. Two of ABC's pilots are "Killer Women" and "Murder in Manhattan." Fox is considering series about a family of assassins working for the U.S. government, about a gang member infiltrating a police force and about a person systematically murdering people in the federal witness protection program.

CBS, which already has a lineup heavy on police procedurals, has ordered "Anatomy of Violence," about a psychologist with expertise on sociopaths. NBC's "The Blacklist" is about the world's most wanted criminal and "Hatfields & McCoys" updates the legendary family feud in a modern setting.

 

Comments

voice of fremont

We need tv shows like in the 50's that promoted good values

Raoul Duke

Yeah, when women and ethnic people knew their place...

gene44870

If they did that most T.V stations would go broke

BULLISDEEP's picture
BULLISDEEP

RTV AND METV subs of channels 11 and 24 already do it , you can also find them online on various web sites.

reporter54

The news is nothing but violence too. The 50s are over unfortunately. It's not safe anywhere and the Beaver is on drugs (or has to take them to remain docile). You can promote all the good values you want but you won't change those for whom it's too late.

KnuckleDragger

Of course they won't cut back. The liberal elite in Hollywood believe that only you should give up your rights. They want Americans to get rid of their guns (2nd Amendment) while they continue to pump out violent movies under the guise of 1st Amendment rights. Remember, liberals believe every right in the Bill of Rights is an individual one except for the 2nd.

CarolinaBuckeye

I agree with reporter54...you ever watch the news...nothing but violence, tragedy and heartache...why? 'cause it sells in mainstream media...its all about the ratings. And please don't talk about violence on TV today if you wont recall the violence on TV in the past; please don't be that jaded. I grew up with the Texas Chainsaw massacre of the 70's and even Tom and Jerry cartoon where they consistently beat the hell out of each other. Yes, that WAS violence. There is a very simple way to solve this...one of two ways...change the channel or don't subscribe to cable or satellite. Read a book.

Señor Clown

Bingo - it's all about ratings, which sells advertising at a premium, which drives profits. The media is a private enterprise, after all. It certainly beats the alternative of a state-run media. I still enjoy watching The Rifleman on RTV, where Chuck Connors dealt with gun violence the only way any sensible person would: By shooting back with better aim. It also depicted a single parent raising a child. For what it's worth, The Rifleman pulled the #4 spot on Nielsen ratings when the first season aired in 1958.

Kottage Kat

Makes me grateful I do not have TV, internet. Or children
the paper on my phone is enough

2cents's picture
2cents

(I do not have TV, internet.)

Are you posting from the library?

vicariouslyAlive

Yes, because its the violence on television that led to such atrocities as the Holocaust, the crusades and the Mexican drug cartels... must have missed where in my history books they accredited all violence in all of history to be relative to the violence we see on TV.

TrollingRageind...

This is ridiculous, and saddening that entertainment is being blamed for people that have something wrong with their brains and murder.
I would love to see less censorship, this is America isn't it? I don't think TV stations should be forced to censor words, they could if they chose, but they shouldn't have to. I don't think certain music should have to be censored to be released either.
Look at rappers, they talk about being and gangster in their "music" and simply capping people. The rapper will talk about the thug and gangster life even when they aren't rapper and even if they aren't a gangster. In metal, the lyrics can get quite graphic and descriptive. In an interview the metal musician is all smiles, laughing, having fun, and most are nicer people than most devout christians.
It is entertainment, it is up to the person to listening/watching/reading to understand that it is fiction or wrong to do, stop trying to blame it on ENTERTAINMENT.

sash

We can blame television and video games all we like, but what about the rest of the world? The same movies and video games are available in Europe, but they don't have the level of violence in society that we do. What about sex? Most European countries have a much more relaxed attitude about nudity and sexuality in advertising, tv and movies than the US. Do they have higher STD's or teen pregnancies? Not at all. We win hands down on those sad statistics too. Although tv, music and video may have some influence, I doubt it has the level of influence most people assume. Complex problems rarely have simple answers, and we'll never find solutions if we focus on one isssue to the exclusion of others.