Senate plan to stiffen border security

Officials finalize immigration reform bill.
Associated Press
Apr 11, 2013


A bipartisan group of senators finalizing a landmark immigration bill has agreed to require greatly increased surveillance of the border and apprehensions of people trying to cross it, a person familiar with the proposals said Wednesday.

The legislation, to be released within days, would call for surveillance of 100 percent of the U.S. border with Mexico and apprehension of 90 percent of people trying to cross in certain high-risk areas. People living here illegally could begin to get green cards in 10 years but only if a new southern border security plan is in place, employers have adopted mandatory electronic verification of their workers' legal status and a new electronic exit system is operating at airports and seaports.

The person provided the information on condition of anonymity because the deliberations were private.

The contours of the tough new border security plans emerged as senators moved closer to unveiling sweeping legislation that would put some 11 million immigrants living here illegally on a path to citizenship and allow tens of thousands of high- and low-skilled workers into the country on new visa programs, in addition to securing the border.

Lawmakers and aides said all the major elements were complete, or close to. A final deal was near on a new visa for agriculture workers. There were small details to be dealt with on visas for high-tech workers, but Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., said it wasn't enough to hold up the bill.

"We are closer now than we have been in 25 years for serious immigration reform," Durbin told reporters Wednesday after he and other Democrats in the Senate negotiating group briefed members of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus. "This president is behind it, and there is a strong, growing bipartisan effort in the Senate to support it. We hope that the House will do the same."

Meanwhile tens of thousands of pro-immigration activists massed outside the Capitol and in cities around the country to push Congress to act. They waved American flags and carried signs reading, "Reform immigration for America now!"

The border security piece of the legislation is critical to getting support from Republicans, but some Democrats have opposed making a path to citizenship contingent on border security. Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., said that the new requirements wouldn't impede citizenship.

"A lot of people here would not want to put dollars into the border, but as a price to get citizenship, as long as it's not an impediment to citizenship but rather works alongside citizenship, it's something we can all live with," Schumer said, after talking to the Hispanic House members. "What we've said all along is triggers have to be objective and attainable in a way it doesn't interfere or delay with people becoming citizens, and that's in the bill."

According to the person familiar with the proposals, the new border security requirements call for 100 percent surveillance of the entire border, and apprehending 90 percent of border crossers or would-be crossers — or getting them to turn back to Mexico — in sectors where the majority of unauthorized entries take place.

As of the end of the 2010 fiscal year, the Department of Homeland Security reported achieving some level of operational control of 44 percent of the nearly 2,000-mile border, according to a Government Accountability Office report this year. Operational control was defined as the ability to detect and respond to cross-border illegal activity.

In one border sector cited by GAO, the busy Tucson sector, 64 percent of people who managed to make it across the border were apprehended in 2011, while 23 percent turned back to Mexico and 13 percent got away. That meant the sector stopped or turned back 87 percent of crossers, close to the 90 percent level sought by the legislation.

The new goals would be achieved by giving the Department of Homeland Security six months from the bill's enactment to create a new border security plan deploying the personnel, infrastructure and technology needed to achieve the 90 percent effectiveness rate. Also within six months, the department would have to create a plan to identify where new fencing is needed on the border. Once those plans are certified, people living here illegally could begin to apply for a provisional status allowing them to work here legally.

If the 90 percent rate of apprehensions isn't achieved in high-risk border sectors within five years, a commission made of border state officials would make recommendations on how to achieve it.

After 10 years, people granted "registered provisional immigrant status" could apply for green cards granting them permanent residency — and the ability to seek citizenship — if the new security and fencing plans have been completed, the mandatory employment verification system is in place and used by all employers, and the new electronic exit system is operating at airports and seaports, collecting machine-readable visa or passport information from airplanes and ships.

The electronic exit system is meant to keep better track of people in the country on temporary visas. Some 40 percent of people in the country illegally arrived with visas but stayed after they expired. The employment verification piece would be an expansion of an existing system called E-Verify that's currently voluntary for most employers, though it's mandatory in some states.

The bill would allocate $5.5 billion for the various proposals, including $1.5 billion for fencing, $2 billion for other border measures and $2 billion to help the commission of border state officials do its work, should that become necessary, the person said, stressing more or less money could be allocated if needed.

The border security details were first reported Wednesday by the Wall Street Journal.


Follow Erica Werner on Twitter:



Darwin's choice

Hahahahahahahahahahaha!!!!!! How about using the worthless border patrol we already have?


I don't think it is the problem of the agents.When this crooked bunch of trash in Wash.imprisons agents for doing their job,there is your problem.How can you expect a border security when the idiots in Wash are buying votes.This government is a disgrace in all parties,except maybe Joe Liberman !Those Repubs. are just as bad as the Dumacrats.They are interested in there paycheck,reelection,retirement and all their perks.Too bad they don't have lead the troops ashore !


How many times are they going to re-invent this wheel??

Licorice Schtick

It's politics. I doesn't need to make sense. Congress is for sale to the highest bidder, through "campaign contributions." Unscrupulous businesses who exploit illegal labor at the expense of American workers will see to it that they are not inconvenienced by anything called "reform."

Everything will remain messed up until we end the corruption.

Thanks to the Citizens United decision, courtesy of the conservative-packed Supreme Court, America is now possessed by wingnuttiness.

At this point, the only way to exorcise this devil and put WE THE PEOPLE back in charge of our own counry is with a Constitutional amendment, correcting the absurd conservative construction that money is "speech," and that giving bags of money to elected officials is "free speech."

Payoff to politicians needs to be banned by the Constitution; it's the only way to get this country back on track.


Though your notion of a "conservative-packed Supreme Court" is laughable, everything else you've said is right on the money, both literally and figuratively.

While one of the things you're right about is stopping payoffs to politicians, I'm not sure that's possible. Even when the front door is closed, there will be backdoor deals and under-the-table exchanges. I think the only REAL fix for the problem is to enact strict term limits. We didn't have these problems when citizens ran for office, served a few years as a SERVICE to their country, and then went back home to tend their farms, businesses, families, etc. It's the advent of the professional politician, the money w#ore who will do anything (literally) to keep his or her job, and who has exempted him/herself from too many of the laws s/he writes, that's doing us in!


Watch the movie Lincoln and see how the 13th Amendment got bought !

Pterocarya frax...

Term limits have done nothing to stop ALEC from buying our entire Republican state legislature.


Increase border surveillance = More camera's so we can watch illegals cross over in the US and not be able to stop them.


Is the Border Patrol going to stop them at the border to register them as Demoratic voters as they enter the country to get their Welcome Wagon gifts of food stamps, free health care, and free education while not paying any taxes?

Tool Box

Lets yank all our overseas troops back to protect our borders instead of getting killed in a foreign land!


Wow. That's a seriously good two-for-one deal! And realistically, isn't our border REALLY what "national defense" is all about?


Close them instead.


I hope they are able to move forward with this legislation. It is good to see a group of Democrats and Republicans working together (although a small number) and compromising and working together to get something that makes some sense. Tool Box makes a very valid point. Let's stop policing the world and take care of things at home. We borrow money from China, Japan, and the Fed to send foreign aid to countries that hate us, yet we have poverty, hunger and many other problems at home. My father always told me that charity starts at home and once you take care of your family then you can take care of others. Let's take care of America before we worry about the rest of the world.