Twinkie maker Hostess reaches the end of the line

Twinkies may not last forever after all.
Associated Press
Nov 16, 2012

Hostess Brands Inc., the maker of the spongy snack with a mysterious cream filling, said Friday it would shutter after years of struggling with management turmoil, rising labor costs and the ever-changing tastes of Americans even as its pantry of sugary cakes seemed suspended in time.

Some of Hostess beloved brands such as Ding Dongs and Ho Ho's likely will be snapped up by buyers and find a second life, but for now the company says its snack cakes should be on shelves for another week or so. The news stoked an outpouring of nostalgia around kitchen tables, water coolers and online as people relived childhood memories of their favorite Hostess goodies.

Customer streamed into the Wonder Hostess Bakery Outlet in a strip mall in Indianapolis Friday afternoon after they heard about the company's demise. Charles Selke, 42, pulled a pack of Zingers raspberry-flavored dessert cakes out of a plastic bag stuffed with treats as he left the store.

"How do these just disappear from your life?" he asked. "That's just not right, man. I'm loyal. I love these things, and I'm diabetic."

After hearing the news on the radio Friday morning, Samantha Caldwell of Chicago took a detour on her way to work to stop at a CVS store for a package of Twinkies to have with her morning tea and got one for her 4-year-old son as well.

"This way he can say, 'I had one of those,'" Caldwell, 41, said.

It's a sober end for a storied name. Hostess, whose roster of brands dates as far back as 1888, hadn't invested heavily in marketing or innovation in recent years as it struggled with debt and management changes.

As larger competitors inundated supermarket shelves with an array of new snacks and variations on popular brands, Hostess cakes seemed caught in a bygone time. The company took small stabs at keeping up with Americans' movement toward healthier foods, such as the introduction of its 100-calorie packs of cupcakes.

But the efforts did little to change its image as a purveyor of empty calories with a seemingly unlimited shelf life: Twinkies, for instance, have 150 calories and 4.5 grams of fat. A Ding Dong chocolate cake with filling has 368 calories and 19.4 grams of fat.

CEO Gregory Rayburn, who was hired as a restructuring expert, said Friday that sales volume was flat to slightly down in recent years. He said the company booked about $2.5 billion in revenue a year, with Twinkies alone generating $68 million so far this year.

Hostess' problems ran far deeper than changing tastes, however. In January, the company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection for the second time in less than a decade. Its predecessor company, Interstate Bakeries, filed for bankruptcy protection in 2004 and changed its name to Hostess after emerging in 2009.

Hostess, based in Irving, Texas, said it was saddled with costs related to its unionized workforce. The company had been contributing $100 million a year in pension costs for workers; the new contract offer would've slashed that to $25 million a year, in addition to wage cuts and a 17 percent reduction in health benefits.

Management missteps were another problem. Hostess came under fire this spring after it was revealed that nearly a dozen executives received pay hikes of up to 80 percent last year even as the company was struggling. Although some of those executives later agree to reduced salaries, others — including former CEO Brian Driscoll — had left the company by the time the pay hikes came to light.

Then, last week, thousands of members of the Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain Millers International Union went on strike after rejecting the company's latest contract offer. The bakers union represents about 30 percent of the company's workforce.

By that time, the company had reached a contract agreement with its largest union, the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, which this week urged the bakery union to hold a secret ballot on whether to continue striking. Although many bakery workers decided to cross picket lines this week, Hostess said it wasn't enough to keep operations at normal levels.

The company filed a motion to liquidate Friday with U.S. Bankruptcy Court. The shuttering means the loss of about 18,500 jobs. Hostess said employees at its 33 factories were sent home and operations suspended. Its roughly 500 bakery outlet stores will stay open for several days to sell remaining products.

In a statement, the bakery union said Hostess failed because the six management teams over the past eight years weren't able to make it profitable — not because workers didn't make concessions.

"Despite a commitment from the company after the first bankruptcy that the resources derived from the workers' concessions would be plowed back into the company, this never materialized," the union said.

Ken Hall, general secretary-treasurer for the Teamsters, said his union members decided to make concessions after hiring consultants who found the company's financials were in a dire situation. But he said that he believed the company could've survived.

"Frankly it's tragic, particularly at this this time of year with the holidays around the corner," Hall said, noting that his 6,700 members at Hostess were now out of a job.

Kenneth McGregor, a shipper for Hostess in East Windsor, Conn., arrived at the plant Friday morning and said he was told he was laid off immediately.

In a statement on the company website, CEO Rayburn said there would be "severe limits" on the assistance the company could offer workers because of the bankruptcy. The liquidation hearing will go before a bankruptcy judge Monday afternoon; Rayburn said he's confident the judge will approve the motion.

"The strike impacted us in terms of cash flow. The plants were operating well below 50 percent capacity and customers were not getting products," he said. "There's no other alternative."

 

Comments

The Big Dog's back

Another failure of a rich CEO.

kURTje

Make them yourself...its that E-Z.

Randy_Marsh

A company has to file for bankruptcy because its creditors cannot be paid. I wonder who Hostess creditors are?
"Ironically, the largest amount of that debt is owed to the unions themselves. When Hostess filed with the bankruptcy court, the company disclosed that its biggest unsecured creditor is the Bakery & Confectionary Union & Industry International Pension Fund, which it owes approximately $944.2 million" http://frontpagemag.com/2012/arn...
Who made who go under again?

wetsu

Yeah, it's the union. They only managed a meager 2.5 billion. Greed did them in. They'll sell off the rights to Twinkies and cupcakes and the higher-ups can buy yachts for their great-grandkids. THAT'S the American way.

FlyBoy86

Psh, they are Hostess Cakes. If you really want something good, go out east and get Tastycakes. They are so much better.

2kids

Tastycakes are AWESOME!! Love them.

totallyamazed

(!)
(!)
WoW, that sucks....guess they won't be able to have their Hostess cake and eat it too. This is a loose/loose situation. 18,000 people out of work.
(!)
(!)

The Big Dog's back

This is a Bain capital (romney) type disaster. Leverage buyout.

Darwin's choice

Really? The Union was asked for an 8% paycut and refused. More voters for your messiah!

Taxed Enough Already

Yes Darwin, I bet that 8% cut is looking a whole lot better than 100% cut in pay. Thank you unions we know you are looking out for OUR best interests... YEAH RIGHT!

ladydye_5

I wondered the same thing, a pay cut or NO job? They interviewed a union rep in Rossford Ohio at the Hostess factory and he said the bankruptcy was the BEST news he had heard. He was sure that another bakery will buy Hostess and they will all get to go back to work!

bored reader

Yeah maybe they will all get back to work with a new owner and no union. Best possible outcome. And take a 16% pay cut. Justice served!

Erie County Resident

Bain Capitol? Really 'lil puppy? That all you have?
Grow up and read the article. Nowhere in there is Bain or any other business mentioned other than Hostess.
Management could have done a whole lot better by not making the stupid moves they made and the union hacks could have done better by not striking in this crash & burn economy. It was a joint effort ... PERIOD!!!

The Big Dog's back

ecr, do you know what a leverage buyout is? I'm not going to do the research for you, but I'll give you a hint. Type in Hostess brands.

2sense

greedy ceo's and the union a sure recipe for failure.

buckeye15

Six management teams over 8 years....I would suspect someone didn't want them to succeed. Selling the same unhealthy crap they have been making for at least 50 years without changing it....not a recipe for success. 80% raises for management when there was no dough...guaranteed to fail.

To blame this on the unions....witless.

2sense

twas both in my humble opinion

Mojo

This is the exact same strategy that Delphi used over 6 years ago. Run the company into the ground by failing management teams then run to New York to file bankruptcy. Steve Miller tactic all over again.

Ehovemom

The reason it is a creditor is because the owners quit funding pensions that they had agreed to fund in contracts. The workers had already agreed two previous times to lower wages, fewer benefits and paying more for insurance. And now they have no pension since the company refused to fund it. According to CBS news, the hedge fund that has been running Hostess plans to sell the trademarked names and recipes for huge profits for themselves.

deertracker

Agreed! This happens more than people realize.

Restless1

"Romney type desaster"? Why not blame it on Bush? Big Dog, you have a one track mind lubricated by the cool aid you blame others of drinking.

Darwin's choice

+1000

Second Opinion

BD is mindless.

4shizzle

Very sad.

Train

Won't mourn the loss of Twinkies. King Dons...yes.

goofus

I find it ironic that two states legalize marijuana and no twinkies !!!
Don't feel sorry for Brutus, even AFL-CIO president Richard Trumka blames Romney for this LOL. This is hilarious!!!!!

jas

The radical right wingers won't be satisfied until we're all working part time jobs with no benefits and getting paid 25 cents an hour just like the Chinese. To blame the collapse of Hostess on greedy unions is totally ridiculous. This company has been mismanaged worse than the Cleveland Browns.

Randy_Marsh

LOL! Blaming a company in bankruptcy for not giving in to the same wages that send then into bankruptcy for the doors closing when the workers walk out. Which planet are you fruits from?

rottnrog

Lets give management who isn't doing their job an 80% raise and tell the workers they have to take a big pay cut, yep, the republican way to do things !!!

Randy_Marsh

Lets think about this for a minute here. The CEO's and all the upper management are still rich, The employees do not have jobs. I wonder if its better to not have a job and actually be so misguided to strike in the middle of a bankruptcy or Still have a job making 18 bucks a hour with any pension? This is why the US is going to go under, Even though the left is sitting under a bridge starving they seem to think they won. In todays market of 14.7% unemployment and half the US on gov support any job is better than none, I could care less if the owner of my company made a million dollars a day as long as i have enough to pay for me and mine.

Pages